Old Fitzgerald is a name that can mean very different things to collectors depending on the bottle. A modern release, an older Bottled-in-Bond expression, a decanter, and a vintage bottle from an earlier production era should not all be treated as the same product.
If you own Old Fitzgerald bourbon and are considering selling it, the first step is to identify the exact bottle—not simply the brand printed on the label. The age statement, bottling details, label design, bottle style, fill level, seal, and original packaging can all help determine whether a particular release is worth submitting for review.
Midwest Whiskey Buyer works with private sellers who have individual collectible bottles as well as larger whiskey collections. You can share the details and photographs of your Old Fitzgerald bottle for an individual review without needing to identify every production detail yourself.
If you are ready to submit a bottle, contact Midwest Whiskey Buyer and include clear photographs of the bottle and its packaging.
Midwest Whiskey Buyer buys unopened Old Fitzgerald bourbon, including vintage Stitzel-Weller bottles and collectible Old Fitzgerald decanters. If you have inherited a bottle or are wondering what your Old Fitz is worth, start with the exact wording on the label. Even one extra word, such as “Very,” can help identify the release.
The following names and details are useful when identifying Old Fitzgerald bottles for submission.
Why the Exact Old Fitzgerald Bottle Matters
Old Fitzgerald has appeared in different formats and across multiple production periods. That makes bottle identification especially important when preparing a submission. Two bottles carrying the Old Fitzgerald name may differ substantially in age, release, presentation, and collector interest.
For example, an older Bottled-in-Bond bottle may need to be assessed differently from a contemporary release. A decanter or special presentation can also have details that are not obvious from a front-label photograph alone.
Rather than assuming that every Old Fitzgerald bottle has the same appeal, a proper review starts with the exact expression and the physical details visible on the bottle.
Which Old Fitzgerald Bottles Should You Consider Submitting?
Old Fitzgerald has several vintage names and bottlings that can look similar at first glance. Read the front and neck labels carefully and include clear photographs so the exact release can be identified.
Very Old Fitzgerald, Very Xtra Old Fitzgerald, and Very Very Old Fitzgerald
Very Old Fitzgerald 8 Year — Often called “Very Old Fitz,” this is an eight-year bourbon to look for among vintage Stitzel-Weller bottles.
Very Xtra Old Fitzgerald 10 Year — Look for the word “Xtra,” spelled without the first “E,” and a ten-year age statement.
Very Very Old Fitzgerald — Known as “Very Very Old Fitz,” this name appears on collectible 12-year, 15-year, and 18-year bottlings. Check the neck and front labels for the age.
Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond, Old Fitzgerald Prime, and Old Fitzgerald 1849
We also buy vintage bottles bearing these names. Photos of the distillery wording and any dates on the tax strip can help us identify your release.
Old Fitzgerald Decanters
We buy sealed Old Fitzgerald Diamond Decanters, recognizable by their diamond-patterned glass and gold detailing, as well as vintage commemorative designs such as the Old Fitzgerald Sons of Erin decanter.
We also buy Heaven Hill’s Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond decanter series. For these newer releases, include the age statement and the spring or fall edition if shown.
Other Old Fitzgerald Bottles and Collections
If you have another Old Fitzgerald expression or several bottles from different releases, you can submit them together for review. Include the exact label wording, bottle size, age statement, and any visible release details for each bottle. Each bottle is assessed individually.
What Does a Buyer Look at When Reviewing Old Fitzgerald?
A bottle's brand name is only the starting point. Midwest Whiskey Buyer buys unopened bottles, and the following details help identify the exact release and assess its condition and collector interest.
Exact expression and age statement: The wording on the label, age statement, proof, and product designation help distinguish one Old Fitzgerald release from another.
Bottling and production details: Label design, tax strip, bottle shape, and other visible details may help place an older bottle in its production period.
Fill level: The amount of liquid remaining is an important condition detail, especially for older bottles.
Seal and closure: The cap, cork, capsule, and seal should be photographed clearly. Do not open the bottle to confirm its contents.
Label and glass condition: Tears, staining, fading, residue, chips, cracks, and other damage should be disclosed in the submission.
Original packaging: A presentation box, tube, decanter stopper, certificate, or other original component can provide useful context.
Collector demand: Interest can vary by release and market conditions. A familiar name does not guarantee that every bottle will be a fit.
How to Photograph Old Fitzgerald Before Submitting It
Good photographs make it easier to identify the exact bottle and understand its condition. You do not need professional product photography; clear, well-lit images taken with a phone are usually a useful starting point.
For an Old Fitzgerald submission, try to include:
For vintage Stitzel-Weller bottles, make sure the wording on the front and neck labels is readable. Include the distillery wording and any dates visible on the tax strip, as these details can help distinguish releases.
Front label, photographed straight on and in focus
Back label and any neck label
Tax strip or other original seal, if present
Cap, cork, capsule, and closure
Liquid level, with the bottle held upright
Bottle base and any moulded or printed markings
Full bottle from the front and side
Original box, tube, decanter stopper, certificate, or inserts
Close-ups of damage, staining, label wear, or missing components
Photograph the bottle as it is. Avoid polishing, soaking, peeling, or repairing old labels. Do not remove a tax strip or disturb the closure. If you are unsure whether a mark is dirt, wear, or part of the original label, leave it untouched and show it in the photographs.
Selling One Old Fitzgerald Bottle or an Entire Collection
You do not need to own a complete collection to make a submission. A single older Old Fitzgerald bottle can be reviewed on its own, and multiple bottles can be submitted together.
If you are submitting several bottles, prepare a short list with each bottle's visible name, age statement, bottle size, and whether the original packaging is included. Separate photographs for each bottle help prevent details from being mixed up.
If your collection includes other collectible bourbon, you can also explore our pages for
selling bourbon and selling whiskey. These pages explain the types of bottles that can be submitted for consideration.
How to Sell Old Fitzgerald Bourbon to Midwest Whiskey Buyer
The submission process starts with the information and photographs you provide. You do not need to create a public listing or prepare a complete collector catalogue before getting in touch.
Step 1: Share the Bottle Details
Send the name shown on the label, age statement, proof, bottle size, and any release information you can identify. If you are unsure about a detail, say so rather than guessing.
Step 2: Add Clear Photographs
Upload the front and back label, closure, fill level, bottle base, and original packaging. Include close-ups of any damage or unusual features that may help identify the bottle.
Step 3: Wait for an Individual Review
Midwest Whiskey Buyer reviews the specific bottle details, condition, packaging, and collector interest. If the bottle is a fit, the team can discuss an offer and the next steps with you. There is no obligation to accept an offer.
To understand the overall process, see How It Works.
What Not to Do Before Selling an Older Old Fitzgerald Bottle
Older bottles can be sensitive to unnecessary handling. A few simple precautions can help preserve the condition and keep the details available for review.
Do not open the bottle or break an intact seal.
Do not remove, replace, or repair original labels.
Do not discard the original box, stopper, certificate, or inserts.
Do not clean the label with water, alcohol, or household products.
Do not guess the bottling year or release; share what is visible instead.
Do not rely on a generic online price for a different Old Fitzgerald expression.
If you want to learn more about label and production clues, our existing guide to
identifying Stitzel-Weller Old Fitzgerald bottles covers identification details. This selling guide focuses on preparing a bottle or collection for buyer review.
Submit Your Old Fitzgerald Bourbon for Review
If you have an Old Fitzgerald bottle that you are considering selling, start by sharing what you know. Whether it is an older Bottled-in-Bond release, a Very Old Fitzgerald expression, a decanter, or part of a larger bourbon collection, the exact bottle details matter.
Send clear photographs of the labels, closure, fill level, and original packaging. Midwest Whiskey Buyer will review the submission and let you know whether the bottle is a fit for a direct purchase.
Ready to get started? Submit your bottle to Midwest Whiskey Buyer for review.
